I’m hooked

A hook, as per the dictionary definition, is something that draws you in. In games, a hook can be a number of different things. Often it is something visually exciting, such as beautiful illustrations, amazingly detailed miniatures, realistic resources or some sort of physical component that is integral to gameplay. Hooks can also be an interesting theme, an exciting gameplay mechanism or even the background story behind how a game was made. Certain awards or even the price of a game can be a hook too. Ultimately it’s about finding something that grabs your attention and gets you to take a closer look.

Some of the physical hooks in tabletop games I can think of include the gears in Tzlok’in by Czech Games Edition, the marble dispenser in Gizmos by CMON and the cardboard tree in Everdell by Starling Games. These are probably components that most people will know, even if they have never played those games. Physical components are a big draw for a lot of people of course. They really enhance the table presence of a game. They are tactile as well, adding another level to playing a game.

Miniatures and realistic resources are another two groups of physical hooks. Miniatures, in particular, have become very popular recently. They not only give the game an enhanced visual presence, but they also have an overlap with another hobby – miniature painting. So if you’re a tabletop wargamer, then games like Rising Sun by CMON or Dwellings of Eldervale by Breaking Games are likely to appeal to you too – and if you enjoyed painting your wargame miniatures, then boardgame miniature painting should keep you busy too.

Illustrations are also great hooks in games and many recently released games look absolutely stunning. My favourite example is Sycthe by Stonemaier Games where Jakub Rozalski has created a whole alternative world which is not only used as a backdrop for the game, but also an integral part of the theme – and theme can, of course, be another hook for games.

There are more non-physical hooks, such as the augmented reality app in Chronicles of Crime by Lucky Duck Games, and there are many more different things that will get your attention, make you look at a game more closely and get you excited. The list is very long indeed and I really only wanted to offer some examples.

A lot of hooks are an integral part of gameplay, but there are games where they’re just gimmicks or novelties that make the game stand out from the rest, but aren’t actually needed to play the game, even though they often enhance the enjoyment of a game from an aesthetic perspective of course, which in itself can be enough.

I don’t want to pick on a specific game, but let me use the tree in Everdell as an example to illustrate where I think a hook has become nothing else than a novelty. The tree doesn’t provide anything that you need to play the game. In fact, the tree uses up a lot of space, and there have been many complaints that in a four-player game the tree actually becomes an annoying obstruction for one of the players or forces everyone to sit closer together to leave room for the tree. However, it does look amazing and really adds to the atmosphere of the game. It does create an impressive table presence.

The marble dispenser in Gizmos is another example of a gimmick, even though I’d argue it actually serves a purpose. You could easily replace the dispenser with a bag and simply draw the relevant number of marbles by hand and line them up on a track. However, the dispenser is great, because it automatically refills the marbles as they are taken, removing the need for you to draw new ones or to have to remember to draw new ones, allowing you to focus on the game. So to me, it’s maybe not integral to gameplay, but certainly makes things more convenient for players.

I think most will agree that the gears in Tzolk’in are not a gimmick. I would say they were innovative at the time, even though you could argue that it would be possible to create the same mechanism by other means, but in reality having to keep track of where things are on the cogs and keeping everything in sync without the gears would have put more pressure on players and created unnecessary housekeeping that would have seriously distracted from gameplay. So even if you don’t think they were innovative, they certainly aren’t just a gimmick.

When we look at the other end of a game’s life cycle, then we’ll find that game designers sometimes start their design with a hook. They may have had a great idea for something that will create interest and then go from there to create a game. They add mechanisms and theme and everything else by using the hook as a starting point. Like with all game design, that is absolutely fine. Game design can start in different ways. Sometimes a mechanism is the basis for a game, sometimes it’s a theme, sometimes an interesting component and sometimes a mix of different things.

However, there have been games where the hook was too heavily relied on to make the game fun and it just didn’t work. Mechanisms, balance, art, theme and everything matter too. I would argue mechanisms and theme are the two most important parts of a good game, but it doesn’t really matter, because ultimately a great hook alone is not going to make for a great game. There is a lot more that is needed to make me want to play a game again and again and again – and enjoy it.

On the flip side, a game without a hook will find it hard to stand out in the deluge of games being released these days. It is almost in the definition of the term. If there is nothing about a game that attracts attention, then nobody will look at it, which means nobody will buy it. However, something that’s a great hook for one person may be a turn off for another. As I said before, someone might be drawn in by stunning artwork, other people might be looking for a game with a new mechanism, others might swear by certain themes or IP in games. We are all different and have different expectations.

What is a hook for you when it comes to tabletop games? Do you care much about hooks? What game did you buy because of a great hook, but then was disappointed when you got to play it? Was there a game that had no specific hook, but had something else that made you really enjoy it? Please share your thoughts in the comments below. I’d love to hear what other people look for in games and how hooked you might get on hooks.

If you like this article, please like it and subscribe to this blog or the podcast. It would help me a great deal. It would be even better if you also tell your friends about them.

Become a PatronIf you like this blog, my videos, podcasts or my other work, please also consider supporting me on Patreon. Even the smallest pledge is highly appreciated: https://www.patreon.com/tabletopgamesblog

Buy me coffeeIf you prefer, you can buy me a coffee via Ko-Fi. I’ll post a photo of it on my Twitter feed so you can share it with your friends: https://ko-fi.com/tabletopgamesblog

Thank you!

Audio Version

Music: Snowy Forest by Kabbalistic Village

YouTube Podcast

You can also listen to this review on YouTube.

Links

IMG_6506

4 thoughts on “I’m hooked

  1. Hooks—I suppose could be similar to Michael Bay’s explosions. A tool from a creative arsenal that can seem overused and extraneous (gratuitous) to some but absolutely core to others.

    Instruments in music can be mixed in odd ways to make the signature sound for an album for some or be the very thing that turns others away.

    Everything does need a hook or we wouldn’t notice it. Fortunately those hooks are varied and many, and some will attract us and some will be dismissed by us.

    Mini mint tin anyone? =D

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your comment. Yes, hooks are important, as per the definition of the word. For subQuark, the fact that the game comes in a mint tin is the hook, but the game itself is so much fun with, or without the tin. The hook in your case is more of a trademark or signature, and the games themselves don’t rely on the hook to be enjoyable. Mind you, a mint tin game where the tin itself is essential to gameplay would be fun. Skulduggery is a nod in that direction of course.

      Like

      1. Mini Apocalypse must use the tin and I’d love that to be true with as many games as possible. For LunaSyr, the tin can be a part of play but truly isn’t (the bottom lid turned upside down is a control tower, but in theme only, not in play).

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Of course, Apocalypse. I’d forgotten about that. The nuclear bunker in the form of the tin and the closing of the lid are very satisfying.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.